Site Information

  Loading... Please wait...


The Decline of an American Furniture Maker

Posted by Beth Macy on

Reprinted from July 2014 New Yorker Magazine

In the mid-twentieth century, Bassett Furniture Industries, in Bassett, Virginia, was one of the largest wood-furniture makers in the world. Its name was the one often inscribed on the back of the bedroom suites behind Door Number Three on “Let’s Make a Deal.” The Baby Boom was on, and people needed to furnish the homes they were buying in the suburbs.

Bassett employed thousands of local people in several factories in town. The J. D. Bassett Manufacturing Company, one of the firm’s subsidiaries, built mid-priced bedroom and dining-room furniture, and Bassett Superior Lines made the company’s lower-priced suites. In between, other plants specialized in chairs, tables, and fiberboard supplies.

Then, in recent decades, came a familiar challenge: Bassett was undercut by imports from Asia and under pressure from shareholders to improve its profit margins. By 2007, it had closed all the plants in Bassett and decided to focus on importing wood products from lower-wage factories in China, Vietnam, and Indonesia. These days, Bassett Furniture places more emphasis, in the U.S., on retail stores, called Bassett Home Furnishings, where it sells mostly imported wood products and custom-made upholstery. In Bassett’s home county, the company now employs only two hundred and fifty people or so. Counting those stores, corporate and warehouse facilities, and its two remaining factories—both outside of Bassett—it now employs fifteen hundred people, down from ten thousand workers at its peak in the eighties.

The Bassett factory closings came not long after many of the region’s textile plants had closed for the same reasons. Between 2001 and 2012, more than sixty-three thousand U.S. factories closed—furniture and clothing mills, shoe and machine-tool factories. There were few places in America where the job losses felt as concentrated as along the eight-mile stretch of the Smith River that is home to Bassett, in the red-clay foothills of Virginia’s Blue Ridge Mountains. In that area, some nineteen thousand workers in the region were displaced between 1990 and 2013.

The situation in Bassett is unusual, though. Unlike in many mill-towns-turned-ghost towns, Bassett workers know about a group of workers similar to them, in a town much like theirs, that has managed to thrive despite the effects of globalization.

That town, seventy miles away, is called Galax. It is the workplace of John Bassett III, a onetime heir to Bassett Furniture who, in 1982, was elbowed out of Bassett—the company and the town—by his older brother-in-law, Bob Spilman, who had visions of his son, Rob, succeeding him as C.E.O.

There, John Bassett resurrected a struggling furniture company called Vaughan-Bassett. In 2003, he organized the filing of what was then the world’s largest petition against China over “dumping,” the illegal practice of selling exports to the U.S. that are priced lower than the cost of their materials. He won. (I document the battle in my forthcoming book “Factory Man.”) Vaughan-Bassett ended up with forty-six million dollars in anti-dumping duties, a development that allowed John Bassett to keep his factory going at the same time as his relatives in Bassett were closing most of theirs. (Bassett Furniture received $17.5 million in duties but used most of the money to buttress its retail expansion.)

Today, Vaughan-Bassett is an outlier in its industry—one of the last bedroom-furniture makers left, as well as the largest. Vaughan-Bassett employs seven hundred people in Galax.

The landscape of Bassett, meanwhile, is deserted. During my initial visit, in 2011 (I returned many times in the following years), I was greeted by a crooked “closed” sign in a café window and an African-American graveyard whose headstones were cloaked in kudzu. Bassett Furniture’s plants sat abandoned on the sides of the company town’s major roads, cordoned off with chain-link fencing and razor wire. At the old John D. Bassett High School, retirees met for exercise in the gymnasium, and residents came weekly for free soup and gently worn clothes. Not long ago, a civic leader was approached outside a pharmacy by a stranger offering a hundred dollars if she’d purchase the cold medicine pseudoephedrine—an ingredient for cooking methamphetamine. Every displaced line worker I interviewed told me that if John had stayed at Bassett some of the town’s factories— especially Superior—might still be running.

Bassett Furniture’s C.E.O., Rob Spilman—the son of Bob, who pushed John out of Bassett—believes the closures, however painful, were needed in order to keep Bassett from having to shut down. “We’ve been a public company since 1930, with shareholders that have to get profits,” he told me. “At the end of the day, we are not a social experiment.” Vaughan-Bassett, in Galax, is privately held; Bassett Furniture is public.

In 2011, Henry County Sheriff’s deputies arrested a thirty-four-year-old man named Silas Crane for breaking into the J. D. Bassett plant. The brick building held copper wiring that Crane intended to rip out and resell on the black market. But he accidentally set the place on fire, burning himself and a trove of warehoused charity goods.

Bassett Furniture was in the process of razing the abandoned Superior building when it, too, caught fire one blustery afternoon in March, 2012. Winds were so strong that the conflagration could not be contained, and the adjacent Bassett Table Company became engulfed, too. Firefighters did manage to keep the flames away from a nearby company warehouse that was stocked with the imports that had rendered the two factories—and the seven hundred workers who’d once worked in them—obsolete.

Displaced workers from across the county drove old pickups and dented sedans to pay their respects, getting as close as they could to the smoke and flames.

False rumors had been circulating, before the fire, that Bassett planned to ship the bricks from the Superior building to China. Maxine Brown, a laid-off worker, told me, “China could get our jobs, our timber, our whole nine yards. But when the building caught fire I thought, At least that’s one brick you won’t get.”

Over the next year, dozens of people stopped by the charred remains of the plant to collect a keepsake brick. It wasn’t just nostalgia that brought them. Sure, they were proud of the work they’d done in those factories, of the friendships they’d formed while culling lumber and carpooling to save on gas. But the people of Bassett also wanted proof of how badly things had ended for them.

Economists, politicians, and others had predicted that trade liberalization, in the nineties and aughts, would help American workers whose wares would theoretically be exported to China’s growing consumer class. Like most Americans, the people of Bassett might never fully understand the intricacies of why things didn’t work out that way. There was China’s movement to artificially lower its currency to give its exports an advantage over competitors, the underpriced “dumping” of Chinese goods, and Chinese government subsidies—all of which allowed Asian-owned companies to sell products at a lower price than their American rivals and expanded the U.S. trade deficit with China.

Maxine Brown and her family had moved from West Virginia to Bassett in 1967. Back then, she said, work was so plentiful that if you left your house to apply for a position in the morning “you might as well take your lunch bag with you—cause you were gonna get a job.” Now, her children and grandchildren leave the county for work. Four have served in Afghanistan and Iraq. Two live in the region but drive to North Carolina for work.

About the only thing Maxine and her husband have left of Bassett is a piece of furniture: a chest of drawers that Maxine helped fashion in Superior’s rough end, the factory department in which lumber is measured and cut. “It’s a keepsake to me, and I can look back on that and say, ‘I helped ’em make it,’ ” she said.

On one of my last reporting trips to Bassett, I stumbled upon a backhoe operator who was burying the detritus of Bassett Superior Lines in a ravine so a landowner (and distant Bassett relative) could use it to extend his lawn. “If you’d told people in Bassett ten years ago that I’d be up here today burying this plant, they’d have said you were a complete fool,” Harry Ferguson told me.

In a corner of the lot stood a neat stack of bricks he’d pulled from the pile. He picked one out and, with a degree of ceremony, chinked off the mortar before passing it to me carefully, the way one might hand over a sleeping baby or a rising loaf of bread.

4 Reasons You Should Hire an Interior Designer for Your Next Home Decor Project

4 Reasons You Should Hire an Interior Designer for Your Next Home Decor Project The way your home is decorated has a major impact on your daily quality of life, as well as potentially adding significant value to your property if you place it up for sale. While your home decor is of course an [...]

Read More »

Furniture Pricing Standards

“Most people do not realize that home furniture has a 200% to 400% markup on it. Some has less, but that is where the majority falls. In fact my friend was a furniture industry insider and at the Highpoint show, a furniture company told him to mark up the price of a wall unit [...]

Read More »

Bonded Leather Horror Stories

Now, before you think we’ve gone and gotten kinky on y’all, please note that the discussion here is about bonded leather, which is sort-of-but-not-really leather that gets used in a lot of things, like that set of encyclopedias you keep around to impress the ladies. For the purposes of this post, we’re talking about furniture [...]

Read More »

Inexpensive Ways to Redecorate Your Bedroom

When it comes to decorating on a budget, the bedroom is often left for last.It hardly seems a priority since it is rarely seen by guests and visitors. But you need to have a comfortable space that is just yours where you can relax and unwind after a long day, or perhaps a retreat for a midday nap. Your [...]

Read More »

​ A Solution-Based Approach to Interior Design

For most of us, the concept of interior design often seems complicated, abstract, or something that you have to just do as you go. Some of the top professionals in the industry, however, know that in order to create a design that is both practical and attractive, you have to use a solution-based approach to [...]

Read More »

Great Ways to Recycle Old Dresser Drawers

Great Ways to Recycle Old Dresser Drawers As more people become eco-conscious, recycling grows in popularity. A great thing about recycling is that people can express their individual creativity. Finding new ways to re-purpose old items is both fun and educational. It also adds a different type of flair to typical home décor. Although many items can be recycled, [...]

Read More »

5 Tips To Help Take Care Of Your Italian Leather Furniture

Everyone knows Italian leather furniture exudes high quality and class, but how can you keep your furniture looking brand-new? Do you have scuff marks or hair clinging to the sides of your armrests? How about that one time your child spilled meatballs all over the upholstery? Well, here’s three tips on how to help take care of your Italian leather [...]

Read More »

Caring for Vintage Furniture

Vintage furniture is an emotional investment if you inherited it from a loved one, or a financial investment if you purchased it to enhance your living space. Knowing how to properly care for and maintain it will enable you to sustain that investment.Conduct an initial inspection to find any imperfections, such as leftover paint or other blemishes that need [...]

Read More »

Tips for Decorating Your Home with Candles

If you are looking for a fun and inexpensive way to decorate your home, candles can help you make it happen. Candles do not cost much, but they can make your home look elegant and charming. Here are some simple tips for getting the most out of your candle-based décor..Have fun with creative candle holders. You do not have [...]

Read More »